Gear guide

Best Paint and Colored Pencils for Pyrography

Picked from Amazon listings, not hands-on tests. How we pick

Color on a wood burning should tint the wood and leave the burned lines readable. That rules out thick, opaque coats and points to three media: soft colored pencils, watercolor pencils used dry or wet, and acrylic thinned with water into a wash. Colored pencils give the most control and are the usual choice on portraits and wildlife. Watercolor pencils lay down color where you want it, then a damp brush spreads it into the grain. Acrylic covers bigger areas fast but must be thinned so it does not hide the burn. Whatever you use, burn first and color second, because heat on paint gives off fumes and scorches the pigment, and seal at the end with a finish that does not lift the color. This guide compares six sets by what each listing states.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change our picks. Affiliate disclosure
New to Prime? Try Prime free for fast, free shipping on eligible items.

Top picks at a glance

Compare all picks
  • Closest match for the job

    Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils, 48 Count

    Soft thick cores blend and layer over burned texture

    See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon
  • Most for the money on paper

    Shuttle Art Acrylic Paint Set, 16 x 12 ml

    16 colors in tubes, easy to thin into washes

    See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon
  • Most complete listing

    Winsor & Newton Studio Watercolor Pencils, 12

    Can be laid down dry and then softened with a damp brush into a wash

    See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon

Compare the picks

The picks in detail

Pick 1 · Prismacolor

Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils, 48 Count

See price on Amazon

Prismacolor Premier 48 soft-core colored pencils in a tin, with lightfast, saturated pigments, a common choice for coloring pyrography.

What the listing offers

  • Soft thick cores blend and layer over burned texture
  • Pigments are described as lightfast, which matters for pieces on display
  • 48 colors cover wood tones, greens and skin tones without mixing

Limits to know

  • Soft cores wear fast on rough or open-grained wood
  • Pricier per pencil than the student sets here
See it on AmazonListing title: Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils, Soft Core, Assorted Colors, 48 Co...

Pick 2 · Winsor & Newton

Winsor & Newton Studio Watercolor Pencils, 12

See price on Amazon

Winsor and Newton Studio Collection watercolor pencils, 12 colors with a break-resistant 3.7 mm core, used dry or wet with a brush.

What the listing offers

  • Can be laid down dry and then softened with a damp brush into a wash
  • Stated excellent lightfastness and high pigment load
  • Colors listed include burnt sienna and black, useful next to burned tones

Limits to know

  • Only 12 colors, so some mixing is needed
  • Water raises the grain on bare wood, so test on scrap first
See it on AmazonListing title: Winsor & Newton Studio Collection, Watercolor Pencils, Set of 12

Pick 3 · Shuttle Art

Shuttle Art Acrylic Paint Set, 16 x 12 ml

See price on Amazon

Shuttle Art acrylic set with 16 tubes of 12 ml and 3 brushes, listed for wood and described as permanent and waterproof when dry.

What the listing offers

  • 16 colors in tubes, easy to thin into washes
  • Listed for use on wood and described as waterproof once dry
  • Three brushes are included for laying in washes

Limits to know

  • 12 ml tubes run out quickly on large signs and panels
  • Thick formula must be thinned well or it hides burned lines
See it on AmazonListing title: Shuttle Art Acrylic Paint Set, 16 x12ml Tubes Artist Quality Non Toxic...

Pick 4 · Apple Barrel

Apple Barrel Essentials Acrylic Paint Set, 12 Ct

See price on Amazon

Apple Barrel Essentials acrylic set with 12 bottles of 2 oz craft paint, satin finish, made in the USA, cleans up with soap and water.

What the listing offers

  • 2 oz bottles give much more paint than 12 ml tubes
  • Satin finish when dry suits signs and home decor pieces
  • Water-based and cleans up with soap and water

Limits to know

  • Craft paint has less pigment than artist acrylic, so washes look paler
  • Bright craft colors need mixing for natural tones
See it on AmazonListing title: Apple Barrel Essentials Acrylic Paint Set, 12, 24 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)

Pick 5 · Crayola

Crayola Watercolor Colored Pencils, 24 Count

See price on Amazon

Crayola 24-count watercolor pencils, pre-sharpened, usable dry or wet, a low-cost way to try color on practice pieces.

What the listing offers

  • Very low cost for 24 colors, good for first experiments
  • Usable dry or activated with a wet brush
  • Pre-sharpened and ready to use straight from the box

Limits to know

  • Marketed for children, with no lightfastness rating stated
  • Harder cores give weaker color than artist-grade pencils
See it on AmazonListing title: Crayola Watercolor Colored Pencils 24ct, Watercolor Paint Alternative

Pick 6 · Crafts 4 All

Crafts 4 All Acrylic Paint Set, 12 Pack, 12 mL

See price on Amazon

Crafts 4 All acrylic set with 12 tubes of 12 ml and 3 brushes, a buttery paint listed for wood, canvas and ceramics.

What the listing offers

  • Low price for 12 colors with three brushes included
  • Listing says it blends easily, useful for mixing custom wood tones
  • Quick drying, so layers can go on in one session

Limits to know

  • Fewer colors than the Shuttle Art set at a similar price
  • Listing gives no lightfastness information
See it on AmazonListing title: Crafts 4 All Acrylic Paint Set - Art Paints for Canvas, Model Painting...

More gear for the color and sealing stage

Burn and Grain chooses every product independently from what its Amazon listing states. We may earn a commission from the links above. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.